> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.vibrantmedia.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# We checked 1,799 page-one results. Small sites hold 29% of them
- URL: https://www.vibrantmedia.com/blog/small-sites-on-page-one/
- Published: 2026-11-12T10:52:37.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-13T09:26:49.000Z
- Description: We pulled the top 10 Google results for 218 small-business questions. Sites under 2,000 visits a month hold 522 of the 1,799 we could attribute. Keyword difficulty was a weak guide to where. The niche was a better one.
- Author: Vibrant Media
- Tags: ai marketing

A small business that starts a blog usually hears the same advice: pick keywords with low difficulty, because page one of Google belongs to big sites. We wanted to see how much of that is true, so we looked at who actually holds page one for the kind of questions a small business would write about.

The answer is a count, not a forecast. It shows who is on page one today. It does not show that a new site can get there, and our own blog is the proof of that, as you will see below.

## The short version

- We pulled the top 10 Google results for 218 questions in five small-business niches and estimated the traffic of every site on those pages.
- 522 of the 1,799 results we could attribute (29%) belong to sites with under 2,000 estimated visits a month. Sites with a million visits or more hold 284 (16%).
- Keyword difficulty was a weak guide. Below a difficulty of 30 it made almost no difference: small sites held 35% of results in the lowest band and 32% in the next one.
- The niche predicted it better. Small sites held 42% of results for health questions and 13% for bookkeeping questions.
- Small sites are not parked at the bottom of the page. They hold 27% of positions 1 to 3 and 32% of positions 8 to 10.

## What we measured

The queries are questions (how, what, why and so on) with informational intent and at least 100 searches a month in the United States. They come from five niches, each started from three seed terms: marketing, home services (plumbing, HVAC, roofing), an online store (backpacks, bags, wallets), bookkeeping (bookkeeping, tax preparation, payroll) and health (dentist, physical therapy, chiropractor).

Inside each niche we took up to 12 queries from each of four keyword-difficulty bands, in an order fixed by a random seed rather than by us. Near-duplicate questions were dropped so one results page is not counted twice. That gave 218 queries: 60 in each of the three lower bands and 38 with a difficulty of 50 or more, because two niches had almost no questions that hard.

For each query we took one snapshot of the top 10 organic results on November 12, 2026\. That is 2,176 results. For 377 of them the data came back as a Google redirect and we could not recover the site, so they are left out. The remaining 1,799 results come from 1,317 different sites.

A "small site" here is one whose estimated organic traffic from Google in the US is under 2,000 visits a month. Search volume, keyword difficulty and traffic estimates all come from DataForSEO. The numbers are printed by one script, scripts/small-site-study.mts in our repository, from a data file stored next to it, so running it again gives the same output.

## How much of page one small sites hold

| Estimated visits a month | Results held | Share of 1,799 |
| ------------------------ | ------------ | -------------- |
| Under 1,000              | 387          | 22%            |
| Under 2,000              | 522          | 29%            |
| Under 10,000             | 810          | 45%            |
| Under 50,000             | 1,074        | 60%            |
| 1,000,000 or more        | 284          | 16%            |

Counted by page instead of by result: 169 of the 218 results pages (78%) had at least one site under 2,000 visits, 82 (38%) had three or more different ones, and 33 (15%) had five or more. These page counts are a floor: a result we could not attribute is never counted as small, and most pages have at least one.

Position on the page barely changes the picture. Sites under 2,000 visits hold 147 of 546 results in positions 1 to 3 (27%), 209 of 727 in positions 4 to 7 (29%) and 166 of 526 in positions 8 to 10 (32%).

## Keyword difficulty tells you little below 30

| Keyword difficulty | Queries | Results held by sites under 2,000 visits | Pages with 3 or more such sites |
| ------------------ | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | ------------------------------- |
| 1 to 14            | 60      | 168 of 480 (35%)                         | 26 of 60                        |
| 15 to 29           | 60      | 166 of 511 (32%)                         | 25 of 60                        |
| 30 to 49           | 60      | 126 of 498 (25%)                         | 21 of 60                        |
| 50 and up          | 38      | 62 of 310 (20%)                          | 10 of 38                        |

The two lowest bands are the same within the noise of this sample. The share of small sites starts to fall at a difficulty of 30, and even at 50 and up one result in five still belongs to a small site. Across all 218 queries the rank correlation between difficulty and the number of small sites on the page is -0.21\. The direction is what you would expect. The strength is weak.

With the bar for "small" raised to 10,000 visits the bands read 54%, 49%, 41% and 32%: the same order, steeper at the top end. So a difficulty score of 12 versus 25 is a thin reason to choose one topic over another. In this sample those two bands sit 3 to 5 points apart, which 60 queries a band cannot tell from noise.

## The niche tells you more

| Niche         | Queries | Results held by sites under 2,000 visits | Pages with 5 or more such sites |
| ------------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | ------------------------------- |
| Health        | 48      | 179 of 430 (42%)                         | 18 of 48                        |
| Marketing     | 48      | 146 of 380 (38%)                         | 10 of 48                        |
| Home services | 36      | 92 of 261 (35%)                          | 4 of 36                         |
| Online store  | 38      | 48 of 299 (16%)                          | 1 of 38                         |
| Bookkeeping   | 48      | 57 of 429 (13%)                          | 0 of 48                         |

The gap between health and bookkeeping is 29 points. The gap between the lowest and the highest difficulty band is 15\. Not one of the 48 bookkeeping pages had five sites under 2,000 visits on it.

Search volume mattered only at the top. We split the queries into thirds by monthly searches. Small sites held 181 of 549 results (33%) in the lowest third, under 210 searches a month, and 207 of 619 (33%) in the middle third. In the top third, 720 searches and up, they held 134 of 631 (21%).

## What this does not show

- **It does not show that a new site will rank.** A small site on page one may have been there for ten years. Two of our own articles target queries where six of the ten sites on page one are under 2,000 visits a month. On the day we checked, neither article was in the top 30.
- **It is not all of Google.** These are questions from five niches, sampled evenly across difficulty bands. The bands can be compared with each other. The overall 29% reflects that sampling, not search as a whole.
- **Traffic is an estimate.** A site the provider scores at 1,500 visits may get more or fewer. We use the estimate to sort sites into rough sizes, not to measure them.
- **One snapshot per query.** Google serves different results for the same query from one request to the next. A second pass would move individual pages, and we did not measure by how much.
- **377 results are missing.** We do not know whether the sites behind the redirects are larger or smaller than the ones we could see.

We also ran the same count on an older set of 63 marketing queries that our own topic picker had chosen, not this sampling. There 185 of 525 results (35%) belonged to sites under 2,000 visits, and the two lowest difficulty bands were again level.

## What we take from it

If you are choosing what to write about for a small site, open the results page before you trust the difficulty score. Count how many of the ten sites are your size. In this sample that count varied more with the subject than with the score, and a low score did not mean a page full of small sites.

And treat that count as a filter, not a promise. It tells you where small sites are allowed in. It does not tell you that yours is next.